Match Every Supplier Invoice to a PO
Every supplier invoice paid without a check against the purchase order is a small bet that it's right.
Most of the time, it is. The problem is the rest of the time.
The exam item
One ROOI exam item reads: Purchase orders are matched to invoices.
It's one of the least exciting items on the exam. It's also one of the easiest places to find money.
$60,000 a year
Here's an example. A company buys $3 million of material a year. If $2 of every $100 is billed wrong and paid anyway, that's $60,000 a year handed to suppliers.
$60,000 a year is pretax profit. It goes straight from your bottom line to someone else's.
How it happens
None of it is fraud. It's just unchecked.
Here's what I've seen on invoices over the years:
- Wrong price. The quote said one thing. The invoice says another.
- Wrong quantity. Billed for 100, delivered 90.
- A delivery that never showed up. Billed anyway.
- Freight nobody agreed to. Added at the bottom.
- Billed twice. Once on the delivery ticket, once on the monthly statement.
Each one is small. Most suppliers are honest and the mistakes go both ways. But when nobody checks, the mistakes that favor the supplier tend to get paid, and the ones that favor you tend to get missed.
Why it doesn't get checked
In a lot of companies, the person paying bills has no purchase order to check against. The material was ordered by phone. The foreman signed a delivery ticket that went in the truck. The invoice shows up a month later, and it looks about right, so it gets paid.
That's not the bookkeeper's fault. The system never gave them anything to match.
Three steps
It's one of the easiest leaks to close. Three steps:
- Issue the PO. Every material order gets a purchase order with the price and quantity.
- Check the delivery. The foreman confirms what actually arrived and notes anything short or damaged.
- Match the invoice before it's paid. Price, quantity and delivery all line up, or the invoice gets a question.
That's it. No new software required, though good software makes it faster.
It helps job cost too
Matched invoices also make your job cost right. When material is billed to the correct job at the correct price, the job cost report tells the truth. That feeds a better estimate next time. Read track the estimate from start to finish.
It also helps your margin. On a tight job, a few thousand dollars of overbilled material can be the difference between hitting the bid and missing it.
Where to start
Pull last month's supplier invoices. Pick ten at random. Try to match each one to a PO and a delivery ticket. Count how many you can't match.
That number tells you how much you're betting each month.
Make it part of the routine
Matching doesn't have to slow anyone down. Make it part of the routine. The PO goes out with the order. The delivery ticket comes back with a quick check from the foreman. The invoice gets matched when it arrives. Anything that doesn't line up gets a phone call before it's paid, not after. Most suppliers will fix an honest mistake quickly when you catch it early.
Check the rest
The ROOI exam asks about PO matching and 19 other systems. You'll see your score against same-size firms, the pretax profit at stake each year and the first step to close each gap. If you're new, start with what ROOI is.