Is Your Markup Policy Written Down?

Written markup policy sheet showing markup by job size and type

Would your estimator put the same markup on Friday's bid that you would?

One of the 20 ROOI exam items reads: We have a written markup policy. Yes or no.

Most owners I ask say no. They have a policy. It just lives in their head.

When markup lives in one head

If markup lives in one person's head, it works until bid day gets busy, a big job is on the line, or that person is out.

Then it turns into a guess. A new estimator uses what the last job had. A tired owner shaves a point to make sure he wins. A big job gets a thin number because it's big.

Without a written policy, markup turns into a negotiation with yourself. The price drops to win the job, and nobody has to explain why.

Same $6 million, $240,000 apart

Here's an example of why it matters. $6 million of sales, two job mixes, and $240,000 of difference in margin. No price changed.

Say a $20,000 job carries $4,000 of margin and a $500,000 job carries $40,000.

Mix A: 50 small jobs and 10 large ones. Margin is $600,000.

Mix B: 150 small jobs and 6 large ones. Margin is $840,000.

Same sales. The small jobs carried a higher markup, so the mix changed the result.

Why small jobs need more

Small jobs take more estimating, mobilizing and management per dollar. A $20,000 job still needs a bid, a crew move, a superintendent's attention and an invoice. Those costs don't shrink with the job.

That's why small jobs should carry more margin, and why the markup at each job size should be set on purpose, not by feel on bid day.

Can you say what markup you use at each size?

What a written policy says

A written policy says three things:

It doesn't set your prices for you. It makes every exception a decision instead of a habit.

Tie it to the return

The policy should come from the return you want. If overhead is $1.2 million and you want $300,000 pretax, the work has to bring in $1.5 million above job cost. Your markup policy is how you get there, one bid at a time. Read markup wins or loses the year.

Check it against your break-even. If margin slips, the volume you need goes up. Read know your break-even volume.

Review the exceptions

The exceptions are where the learning is. If the same kind of job keeps getting a lower markup, maybe the policy is wrong for that work. If one estimator goes below it every week, that's a training conversation. Without a written policy, you can't see any of that, because there's nothing to compare against.

Write it this week

Start with one page. List your job sizes. Write the markup you'd put on each. Name who can go below it. Hand it to your estimators and ask them to tell you every time they do.

After a few months, look at the exceptions. You'll learn a lot about where your margin goes.

The ROOI exam asks about your markup policy and 19 other systems. You'll see your score against same-size firms, the pretax profit at stake each year and the first step to close each gap.

Take the free ROOI exam

LinkedIn Facebook X

More on this