Growing Sales, Shrinking Profit: What Happened?
Here's an example. Last year, $5 million in sales and $350,000 pretax. This year, $7 million in sales and $210,000 pretax.
That's 7 cents kept on each dollar sold, down to 3 cents.
The company got busier and kept less.
It happens more easily than you'd think
It happens more easily than you'd think. I've watched it happen to good companies, and I've felt the pull of it myself.
Here are the usual causes:
- Bigger jobs bid thinner to win them. The new work came in at a lower margin than the old work.
- New hires before the systems to manage them. More people, more mistakes, more rework.
- Overhead that grew faster than margin. Every new hire made sense alone. Together, they outran the work.
None of these feel like bad decisions when you make them. They feel like growth.
Same sales, $900,000 apart
Here's the other side of it. Two contractors each do $8 million in sales. One keeps $900,000 pretax. The other breaks even.
Same volume. A $900,000 gap.
Volume doesn't explain it. They did the same volume.
So look at the systems behind the work. How jobs get priced. How overhead gets budgeted. How labor hours get estimated and tracked. How people get paid.
That's where the gap lives. Not in how much work came through the door, but in what the company did with it.
Sales tells you how busy you were
Sales tells you how busy you were. Pretax profit tells you what the work was worth.
Our industry talks about sales volume a lot. Trade magazines rank companies by it. Owners compare it at conventions. But a bigger number at the top doesn't pay anyone if it doesn't reach the bottom.
That's why I measure the return on overhead instead. Read what ROOI is and why profit on sales can hide the real story.
Growth isn't the goal
Growth isn't the goal. Pretax profit is.
Growth can be a good way to get there. Sometimes you add overhead first and the return dips before it comes back. That can be fine if it's planned. Read the growth dip.
The problem is growth that nobody planned, priced or measured. That's how a company ends up with more trucks, more people, more stress and less money.
What to check before you grow
Before chasing the next big step in volume, I'd check:
- What margin does the new work really carry?
- What overhead will it take to run it?
- Do we have the people and systems to manage it?
- Will the return on overhead go up, or just the sales?
- Can our bank line and bonding carry it?
If you can't answer those, the extra volume is a bet.
Look at margin, not just volume
When sales grow, look at what each new job really earned, not what it was bid at. In my experience, the slide in profit almost always shows up there first. A few thin jobs won to keep crews busy can quietly undo the margin on everything else. If you catch it in the monthly numbers, you can change what you bid next. If you wait for year-end, you just get to read about it.
Check your systems
The ROOI exam looks at the systems that decide whether more work means more profit. 20 yes-or-no questions about pricing, overhead, labor and pay.
When you finish, you see your score against same-size firms, the pretax profit at stake each year and the first step to close each gap. The free planner after it helps you set a sales goal that grows the profit, not just the volume.